$7 Amazon E-Gift Card to one lucky reader who leaves their email address in a comment on this post by midnight PST on Monday, May 21st. I will only use your email addie to contact the winner. Will not keep addies.

05-19 Sarah Raplee – Riff on 7 yrs. Of SPAM & a Giveaway

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

I Should Write a Book

Identifying the specific traits that make a writer is a difficult assignment. By contrast, defining a non-writer is easy. The non-writer talks (and talks and talks) but never actually puts his fingers on the keyboard.

I’ve stopped discussing my projects with these non-writers. Why? Because the response is nearly always the same: “You know, I should write a book.” And of course, that profound statement is consistently followed by: “It’ll be a best seller.”

In a prior life (last year), I tried to help these wayward souls reconnect with the mother-ship. Below is a compilation of my attempts.

ME: What will your book be about?
Clueless in Seattle: It’s about a wizard. He goes to Rome to save Catholicism by killing the Pope—who’s turned into a vampire.
Cole Kreme: I don’t know but it’ll have lots of sex so it won’t be boring.
Ima Borin: It’ll be my life story, starting with my advanced mastery of potty training and will continue on through my fourth marriage.
Nita Klue: It’s about this mermaid. Except she doesn’t have fins and she doesn’t live in the ocean.
Olive Miya Poopa: I plan to write about how toilet paper is made. It’ll be a kid’s book.
Future Bestsellers (Multiple People/Personality): It’s about my mother (father/child/ex-husband/drill sergeant/psychiatrist). My therapist says it’ll be good to get it down on paper.

ME: What genre do you plan to write?
Morrel, Marge R.T.: Oh, I don’t write that racy stuff. I want something the entire family can read.
Drew A. Blanque: There are no Johns in my book.
Clueless in Seattle: My book will be written in English.
Ima Borin: I thought I’d just use regular paper.

ME: Have you taken any writing classes? Attended any workshops?
Paige Turner: I took four years of high school English. Since my poem won first-place in the third period “Beauty of Spring” contest, I don’t need any more classes.
Otter Noah: I don’t need any classes. My book will write itself.
Clueless in Seattle: You have to take a class to write a book? That’s just not fair.
O. Mai: Workshops? Is that for binding the book once it’s written?

ME: Do you know anything about manuscript formatting?
Clueless in Seattle: I’m not writing a manuscript, I’ll write the whole book.
Nita Klue: My editor will take care of all that stuff.
Doug A. Hole: I’ll just do a hardcover book. I’m not too fond of those computer novels.

ME: You know writing is hard work, right?
Chase N. Mattel: Nah. I’ll just use the tape-recorder on my way to Myrtle Beach. My wife can type my novel when we get home.
Heir, Hedda: How hard can it be? You think, you type, you staple the pages together.
Clueless in Seattle: Whaddya mean? Like it’ll take more than a month?
Otter Noah: Maybe for you, but my book will write itself.

ME: Do you have a publisher in mind?
Doug A. Hole: Once I finish with my book, I figure I’ll just look at the NYT Bestseller list and contact the company that has the most books on it. They’ll jump at the chance to publish me.
Missy N. Link: Well, once I go on the Today Show, that’ll take care of my publicity.

ME: So have you actually started your novel?
Heir, Hedda: No, but the entire book is in my head.
Chase N. Mattel: I plan to write it over the holidays.
Noah Deia: I haven’t started the book, but I’ve finished the forty-eight page prologue.
Liam Malone: No, but I plan to start as soon as my kid (spouse/lover/mother) starts first-grade (high school/college/drinking (okay, so no one said drinking, but they should have)).
Otter Noah: I’m in no hurry, my book will write itself.

Identifying the specific traits that make a non-writer is obviously easy. Can we back into the making of a writer by applying the opposite? If so, a writer is committed, craft-savvy, and disciplined.

In conclusion, do we try to educate the non-committed masses who think writing a book is easy? Or should we just cop out with a grin, a nod, and a "yeah, you really should write that book?"

NOTE: Actual responses have varied, but are only slightly exaggerated; names have been changed to protect the ignorant, eh . . . I mean innocent.


Linda Lovely said...

Robin, you had me laughing out loud. The non-writer category I encounter the most is the memoir writer, who (for no good reason) thinks his/her life will be a blockbuster best-seller that will become a movie starring Sandra Bulloch or Brad Pitt.

Olive Payne said...

Robin, That article is too funny and unfortunately too true. I know Paige Turner. :) How many of these types of people would you say belong to a chapter of RWA?

Sandy said...

We've met them all at some point ... best to nod and smile. I love the names you created ;-)

Robin Weaver said...

Hi Linda,

I hear ya about Brad and Sandra/Angelina/Reece playing the leads. Of course, Anjelica Huston or Helena Bonham Carter get to play the mommy dearest, right?

Robin Weaver said...

HeySarah (Olive),
Great to hear from ya! I don't count RWA members in the talkers group. IMHO, if you go to a meeting, you're already miles ahead, right?

Sarah Raplee said...

The types of people you so hilariously roasted here don't bother me nearly as much as the ones who have 'a can't-fail' idea for a book, but want ME to write it for them. Some even offer to split the royalties with me! One insisted on giving me her notebook outline for a thriller that 'came to her' but that she felt unable to actually write herself. I later discovered that Ken Follett has already written that book. It was a bestseller, of course.

Tam Linsey said...

Great post! You had me laughing hard. I'm with Sarah - I hate most of all the ones who say "You should write my life story!" Little do they know, they are already "in" some of my manuscripts. Hee hee!

Judith Ashley said...

You've missed your calling. I think comedy is in your future. What makes your post so funny to me is that it is so real...I've not met everyone on your list but I have met some of them.

PS: I'm not sure I believe your caveat that the actual responses have been changed at all.


Ro said...

Forget educating the non-committed masses! Grin, nod, and keep gathering more of this great material.


Robin Weaver said...

Thanks all for your comments. What about those folks who not only don't write, but proceed to tell you what YOU should do?

Anonymous said...

Excellent! Three cheers for the CRAFT, and the workshops, and the critique groups, and the rewrites, and the rewrites and the rewrites!!

Pat McGroin

Anonymous said...

Great blog! Really funny!! -Camille

Booque Marq said...

Hi Robin,
I agree with you whole heartedly...most of the folks who think they should write a book are not able to put a sentence toghether with any structure or sense. Also, I find talking to them a great waste of my they speak only of themselves - so I want to read 150 pages about more YOU...NOT! I am going to write a book soon - and I have the title...see if you agree "I am too stupid to own a SmartPhone"...let me know.

Booque Marq

Booque Marq said...

and if only I would proofread my work...together would be spelled correctly! Sorry to mess up your blog!

Robin Weaver said...

Hi Booque, Your title was too funny.

Booque Marq said...

Well, I am sure knowing me - as you do - it is quite the apt title!

As may well imagine - it would be a very short book...

Booque Marq