Saturday, October 29, 2022

Where Did All the Meaning Go? How Halloween Lost Its Roots by Heather Michet

Once upon a time not that long ago, the end of October brought celebrations of gratitude, reverence and honoring: the harvest was in, plants and planets that sustained life were thanked, and people readied themselves for the coming darkness and quiet of winter while acknowledging the dead and their part in the natural order of things.

 Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash


Now this time of year in the US means more plastic junk, too much sugar, ghoulish décor and wacky outfits.

How Did We Get Here?

What began as a ceremonial, earth-based, spiritual time with bonfires, harvest foods, and communing with the dead, has become a ghoulish, commercialized observance.

Here’s what happened (in a very simplified form):

  • Ancient Celts celebrated the end of summer, the harvest, and the threshold between light (summer) and dark (winter) with their Samhain fire festival.  Happening over 3 days - October 31st–Nov 2nd – spirits of the dead were believed to be more visible and approachable during this liminal time.


  • Catholic popes attempted to “Christianize” Samhain.  This was done in an attempt to spread their religion and wipe out pagan traditions. Nov. 1st became All Saints Day, aka All Hallows Day, making October 31st All Hallows Eve.  Nov. 2nd became All Souls Day. Note that the word pagan comes from the Latin ‘paganus’ which means villager or rustic, ie. a country dweller.  The Church moved the meaning to heathen.


  • Romans had their own fall festival which included honoring Pomona, the goddess of fruit and trees. There’s where our bobbing for apples at Halloween parties came from!


  • Irish immigrants in mid-19th century left the potato famine to come to the US, bringing many of the familiar Halloween traditions that we see today, including Jack-o-lanterns.  The early carvings, however, were out of beets, turnips and potatoes.


From Bonfires to Billions

Trick or Treating was popularized in the States in the 1950’s, beginning the rise to the celebration’s big revenue producer that it is today: More than 179 million people celebrate Halloween in the US, spending $10.6 BILLION.  Yes, billion with a B.

Photo by Lucas Ludwig on Unsplash

What Happened to Remembering the Dead?

By disrespecting our dead and death itself with our Halloween traditions, we have fueled our fear of death.  With the dead portrayed as gruesome, gory monsters and zombies, who wouldn't be scared of talking about death and dying?

In her wonderful book Wintering: The Power of Rest and Retreat in Difficult Times, Katherine May states it perfectly: 

“Our contemporary celebrations forget the dead altogether…We are, after all, a society that has done all it can to erase death…the idea that we might be intimate with death is now some kind of a gothic joke.  Today’s Halloween simply reflects what we secretly think – that death is a surrender to decay that makes us monsters.”

Who Wouldn’t Be Afraid of Death?

I feel that in disrespecting our dead - and death itself - with our Halloween traditions, has fueled our fear of death.  With the dead portrayed as gruesome, gory monsters and zombies, who wouldn’t be scared of talking about death and dying?

Photo © Heather Michet

Mexico Saves the Day

Thankfully, one culture’s practice of celebrating and honoring the dead is thriving: Mexico’s Dia de los Muertos.  It is colorful, respectful, bright and meaning-filled, taking place on November 1st and 2nd.

I love this holiday!

Photo © Heather Michet


The best way to learn more about this festival is to attend a celebration in your community.  

If that’s not an option, watch the film Coco, one of my absolute favorite movies.  The story portrays the practices and meaning of this holiday beautifully. 

You can also read about the rituals I include at this time of year here.

You Can Be a Meaning Maker

Talk with your children, grandchildren and other adults about the true meaning behind Halloween.

It will make a difference in their lives and in our world.

Heather Michet is an impassioned healing artist, educator and Ceremonial Songstress who weaves lyrical, a cappella vocals throughout a wide array of ceremonies in a myriad of settings.  From weddings in the woods, graveside memorials, and ashes scatterings at the shore, her Celtic style voice embraces the heart and stirs the spirit of all who gather honoring life events.  You can connect with Heather and her work in any (or all!) of these ways:


9 comments:

Mindy Hardwick said...

Halloween is a playful, fun holiday for children and adults to dress up and enjoy a night running from house to house for candy. It is a night of imagination and creativity. The town where I live has a Halloween parade. It's great to teach children about the history of Halloween and as a teacher I do this, but it's also important to allow for the fun of that night too. Allow the child in yourself to come out on this night and I think it might be more fun.

Anonymous said...

Halloween has an interesting history.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge and thoughts. Strangely enough, I think you and your first commenter both have valid points.

Anonymous said...

If I was a Witch stirring a cauldron for you:
I’d ask the sweet mommies to add a pinch of salt to the brew.
As children grow older add more, just a tad,
so they understand history, both good and the bad.
I’d ask storeowners to put ghoulish displays,
not in the entrance, but further away—
A young grandson was stricken- for weeks he was fearful.
The screams were so sad- it was really an earful!
I’d give time to the ancestors and wish them good rest,
and teach growing children to give them their best.
If we want a country that is both SWEET and JUST—
telling children the truth as they grow is a must!

Diana McCollum said...

Enjoyed your post!

Halloween is one of my favorite holidays! I agree with the first comment in that to let loose and dress up and enjoy all the costumes is part of the joy of Halloween.

I love decorating for it. I only wish we lived where there are trick or treaters, unfortunately we live in the country so no trick or treaters. It doesn't matter, I still decorate. Homage to those who went before.

Day of the Dead, is also celebrated here when thoughts and discussions turn to those who have passed on.
Happy Halloween!

Heatherm said...

Hi Mindy! Thank you for reading and commenting. I'm thrilled to hear that you teach your students about Hallowe'en's history and that you enjoy the celebrating so much.
My child self and imagination do indeed get lots of play time; it's so very important! We're all more playful at times other than Hallowe'en.
I trust you've had a fabulous time this year :)

Heatherm said...

Dear Anonymous - I appreciate you reading and sharing your thoughts and impressions and I agree with you: both Mindy's and my feelings about Hallowe'en can happily and easily coexist!!
If it's the same Anonymous (#1, we'll say) who posted the poem...WOW!!! I really love it. Thank you so much!

Heatherm said...

Ghoulish and scary greetings to you, Diana!
Thank you for reading my post and for sharing all of your comments. Yes, yes, YES! I especially love your statement "Homage to those who went before."

Much gratitude to you for remembering the dead and honoring them.

Judith Ashley said...

Heather, I think it important to know the history of our beliefs and celebrations not so we change them (unless we choose to do so) and more because it gives us a richer foundation as well as something to ponder.

Heatherm said...

Dear Judith - Thank you for reading and commenting. I so agree about how important it is to learn about our celebrations and their meaning.