Wednesday, April 9, 2025

Comfort Comes In Many Forms

 

When I saw this month’s topic was “favorite comfort reads” all I felt was distress. My world is nothing but stress right now. I grew up in a country that, while not perfect, seemed to want to do better. So I was encouraged and hopeful and optimistic. I loved reading lighthearted romances and when I wrote, a happily ever after, or at least for now, came naturally to my books.

 
Then disasters descended around me. When I looked around a few years ago and that desire to do better became scarce. Maybe it was Covid, maybe MAGA, certainly social media and the search for “likes” amid the direction of the algorithm provided coals to the fire. Certainly the growth in book banning slapped me in the face, along with learning that one of the books I wrote, Courage, is one of many used to train AI bots.  BTW, Thank you, Author’s Guild for fighting this.

 
Add in a few personal health issues, and now money issues from this insane trade war the president ignited, and comfort began to feel impossible. Darn it, I had been planning to attend the 2025 Romance Writers of Amereica conference in Niagra Falls, Ontario as an excuse to visit Canada again. Now I don't think the country will be very welcoming.

 
There I was, feeling there was no comfort for me to write about this month. Then, while I was listening to the radio (yeah, some of us dinosaurs still care about radio)  an old song came on.


It's the end of the world as we know it and I feel fine
 by R.E.M. - Composers: Bill Berry, Mike Mills, Michael Stipe, Peter Buck

It was written in the 1980s. You have to be old as dirt to remember it, but then again, I am. You can click the image below to hear the song on YouTube.


I instantly felt better after hearing it. The song fit me, came pretty much as close to real comfort as possible. The words are an incredibly prophetic downer, but the music and tone are upbeat and energetic. That song, those lyrics, that beat almost made me welcome the end of the world I knew. I had to ask myself, why would such a total downer lift my spirits? Maybe its just the kind of person I am.  I remember my sister died of a lingering illness in 1997, the same year the movie Titanic came out.  I went to the theaters more times than I could count, just to watch that boat sink. I knew exactly the right time to walk in to watch the frantic passengers racing back and forth while musicians played to keep their own spirits up. The mother who realizec there was no escape, and read a story to her children to keep them as calm as possible. The elderly couple lying in bed, clinging to each other as the water rose. And the hundreds of people who went down with the ship, to freeze or drown or both. I'm sorry to be morbid, but at that time, watching hundreds of people die somehow helped me deal with the loss of my sister. And once the boat went down, I got up and left the theater.


Anyway, fast forward from 1997 to 2025.  The R.E.M. song led me to think of dystopian and disaster stories. It was just in time for me to get my hands on the newest Hunger Games book, Sunrise on the Reaping. There isn't too much I can say, the book is still very new. On the other hand, there aren't a lot of spoilers, not if you've read the other books. Two things went through my mind as I started chapter one. First, I already know what was going to happen. There is no happy ending in this book. If you know about the world of Panem and the Hunger Games, you know on page one that a lot of people, mostly kids, are going to die in some horrible ways in a so-called game. That Haymitch Abernathy, the sixteen-year-old sole survivor of the game will be so traumatized he will become an unloved, alcoholic hermit in District 12 for the next twenty-five years.  

What I didn't know were the details. Haymitch's bravery. The kids whose deaths he witnessed, the ones he caused, and the ones he tried, and failed, to save. And his secret mission against the Capital, his efforts to stay alive long enough to accomplish that mission in hopes of making his country a better place, even if it earns the undying hatred of the villaneous President Snow.

I don’t know why this book became my happy place in spite of the misery and pain, cruelty and loss.  It sent me back to re-reading the entire series. I have to admire how neatly Suzanne Collins made this book fit  into the middle of the existing Hunger Games universe. Not one of the five books has a legitimate happy ending. Terrible things happen, and people we feel deserve a happily ever after wind up gutted like Haymitch, or dead, while the villains triumph time after time. But sometimes comfort isn’t just about hearts and flowers and marriage vows. Sometimes its something: a song, a movie or a book, that grants me permission to feel what I feel, good or bad. 


5 comments:

Judith Ashley said...

Barbara, this post has touched me deeply. I too am 'old as dirt' so I do remember the REM song. I was in my 40's in the 1980s. I've not watched Titanic from start to finish but I have watched parts because it was a favorite movie of my youngest granddaughter and she played it numerous times. I've also not read any of the Hunger Games but as I read your words about the latter, the inspiration of Haymitch, someone who did what he could against what were insurmountable odds, putting himself at risk, to do what he could ... after all that's all any of us can do: stand up the best we can to protect what we hold dear, what and whom we value and at the very least interfere, slow down and if possible stop the evil around them.

Thank you for sharing your words of inspiration with me this morning.

Diana McCollum said...

Great blog post!

Sarah Raplee said...

Barbara, I too vaguely remembered this song. Thank you for the reminder. The words give voice to what many are feeling, yet the music is uplifting, even celebratory.

Perhaps the books of the Hunger Games Series resonate because they don't sugar coat the sacrifices made to stand up to evil, to "change the things I can" as it says in the Serenity Prayer.

Things will no doubt get worse before they get better, but I have faith they will get better. I try to turn over the things I can't change to God and concentrate on doing what I can. I used to feel an obligation to witness every tragic story, but doing so changes nothing and and leaves me constantly grieving and overwhelmed. Instead I look for ways I can effect change or join others to effect change. Volunteering helps.

Thank you for you insightful post.

Barbara Rae Robinson said...

Wow! Love your blog and the video, which I had not seen. I'm older than dirt. The 80s were a traumatic time for me that included losing our youngest son at the age of 21. I watched The Titanic because I was fascinated by the tragedy. In college, in a history of journalism class, I had written a term paper on the newspaper coverage of the sinking of the Titanic. I already knew a lot about the tragedy when the movie came out. Your post and the video have given me a lot to think about. Thanks.

Lynn Lovegreen said...

Great post, Barbara. I hear that horror is coming back because people want to learn how to survive. I think your reading dystopia is another good strategy. (And I love that REM song, too!)