Well, last month I messed up and used this month's theme of "Adventures in Travel" for last month's blog post about writing the book of my bicycle journey around the world:
https://romancingthegenres.blogspot.com/2019/07/every-book-has-its-time.html
I figured that this month I should look at my "travels" in writing.
Recently I was part of a small group discussion about the drop-out rate of authors from the industry, many of them with reasonably established careers. We talked a bit about why it happens. I eventually proposed a "model" but I've given it a lot of thought since and wanted to explore this a bit more.
I'm not talking about the "fad" writers. "Oh, everything with Girl in the title is hot, I'll write one of those." "Oh $0.99 books with massive ad campaigns are the answer to everything." Most of these folks are gone as quickly as they arrived. I'm talking about people who want to have a good, consistent writing career.
There are a number of hurdles to clear, things that can really stop authors in such a way they may never recover:
- Actually finishing and letting go of (publishing) that first book.
- The terror of the blank page of the second book especially after all that pretty polishing of the first.
- Five books later, discovering that this career requires hard, consistent work, and that success rarely just dangles from the trees. Yes, there are the breakout writers, but I'm not talking about those, I'm talking about steady, workaday writers like myself.
But once they clear the five-book hurdle, most authors seem able to continue up to that 20-book threshold. Then a massive winnowing happens at this point and this is what aroused my (and the group's) curiosity.
Why at 20 books?
By then, especially if the author focused intelligently on a genre or series, income is often moving nicely. Maybe not stellar yet, but probably a decent income. They know how much work it is.
And then they just walk away.
My theory on this is actually tied up in my own recent experience. I have fifty-two romance novels across multiple series. But 12 of those are in contemporary romance, which is quite different from writing military romantic suspense. And the military rom was split up across multiple series and the last 9 years (so I wrote many other things in between, perhaps bypassing that 20-book trip point that way).
But why at 20 books?
My theory is that most of the truly long career writers I've spoken to have had to reinvent themselves. Either the industry or the traditional publishers' perception of the industry created tectonic-scale shifts and suddenly Gothic romance, westerns, horror, Cold War thrillers, science fiction in general, and so on simply were no longer a viable option. A writer who wrote 20 novels without being "forced" to reinvent themselves would consider that they'd had a good run.
Then along came indie publishing. Now we are able to reach an on-going audience despite any trends or perceived trends. We are free to write 40 military romantic suspense novels as part of a career with no clear pressure to reinvent ourselves.
I think that this is the real 20-book trap. Twenty novels is typically between 1 and 2 million words. Isn't it time for a break? For a change up? For a refreshing of motivation? You don't have to do as I have and jump whole genres, but shifting from mystery to thriller, from noir to cozy, from space opera to apocalyptica, even small-town romance to urban romance. These kind of changes keep us fresh as writers. At least that's my theory.
Yes, many careers were ended by the "tectonic" shifts of the past, but how many more were created anew by an author reinventing and refreshing themselves? I'd wager the later number is far bigger.
I recently noticed that my own instinctive writer was looking for a change. My last several military romantic suspense novels have been reviewed with "thrilling, fast-paced, adventure" far more than heart-felt romance as they used to be.
So? I've decided to listen to that for a while. I'm not abandoning romance. But for now, I'm working very hard to reinvent myself as a thriller writer. We'll see how that goes...
Coming November 19th and December 17th the Miranda Chase NTSB thrillers:
![]() |
More Info / Pre-order |
A supersonic drone flies Black Ops
missions from the most secure hangar in the nation.
A C-130 Hercules transport plane lies
shattered in the heart of America’s Top Secret military airbase — Groom Lake in
the Nevada Test and Training Range.
China’s newest stealth J-31 jet fighter
goes missing.
The CIA, the military, and the National
Reconnaissance Office are all locked in a power struggle.
One woman is trapped in the middle.
Miranda Chase, lead crash investigator for the NTSB (National Transportation Safety
Board), becomes a pawn in a very dangerous game.
Burdened with a new team, she must
connect the pieces to stay alive. And she must do it before the wreckage of her
past crashes down upon her.
Think I'm right or wrong? I'd love to hear your thoughts on the challenges facing career-writers.
---
M.L.
“Matt” Buchman started the first of over 60 novels, 100 short stories, and a
fast-growing pile of audiobooks while flying from South Korea to ride his
bicycle across the Australian Outback. Part of a solo around the world trip
that ultimately launched his writing career in: thrillers, SF/F, and romance.
His
titles have been named Barnes & Noble and NPR “Top 5 of the year” and
3-time Booklist “Top 10 of the Year” as well as being a “Top 20 Modern
Masterpiece” in romantic suspense. As a 30-year project manager with a
geophysics degree who has: designed and built houses, flown and jumped out of
planes, and solo-sailed a 50’ ketch, he is awed by what's possible. More at: www.mlbuchman.com.